Take a look at my new website at https://www.pelletiercraftstudio.com

Looking for Retreat House Rental?  Click here!

Choosing an album when you are getting started scrapbooking can be overwhelming. There are so many options out there to choose from, not to mention they can be expensive. I’ve tried so many albums over my many years of scrapbooking and found there are some important factors to look for when choosing your scrapbook album.

We R Memory Keepers D-Ring Album

So, do you know what makes a good scrapbook? The best scrapbook albums are sturdy and durable. When shopping, ask the sales associates which album is their favorite or best-seller. You’ll want to pick each up, flip through the pages and see how well the book is constructed. Make sure it’s durable. The next thing to find out is if the album will stand up to years of handling. Next ask about the product line. You’ll want to make sure that when you’re ready for your next album the same type will still be available. The third thing to consider is what type of album you like best. The three most popular styles are a D Ring, post-bound or a strap bound album. My favorite album is the We R Memory Keepers D-Ring Album. They are available in several different sizes and are super durable.

See We R Memory Keepers D-ring Album at Amazon.

These are probably the most important factors to keep in mind when shopping for a scrapbooking album. But there are a few more things to keep in mind when making your choice.

Picking The Right Album

Choosing an album is an important step when scrapbooking, especially when first getting started. You go through all the care and hard work of crafting each scrapbook page. It’s special and you’ll want it to be treasured for years to come. One of the best ways to do that is to make sure to choose the right scrapbooking album.

As I mentioned above, there are three important things to look for when choosing the right scrapbooking album:

  • Durability
  • Will it be available in the future
  • Which kind of album do you like (Post Bound, D-Ring or Strap Bound)

How much do you want to spend?

Another consideration when choosing an album will be the price.

On average, a good quality, 12 x 12 album will likely cost around $40.

Post Bound12 x 12$20 to $40
8 1/2 x 11$15 to $25
8 x 8$10 to $20
D-Ring12 x 12$25 to $55
8 1/2 x 11$15 to $30
8 x 8$20
6 x 6$10
Strap Bound12 x 12$40
Scrapbook albums can be a good predictor on quality. However, has not influence in how easy the pages can be loaded.

Which material is best?

The material on the outside cover of your scrapbook will make a big difference in your album’s longevity and beauty.

Leather is by far the best material for a scrapbooking album. It is durable, long-lasting and easy to keep clean. This is my number 1 choice of material.

I love the one with the metal corners, as the corners seem to get the most wear and tear. A metal corner helps protect them from getting dents and torn.

In my opinion, the albums that fare the worst over time are cloth or linen. They are bound to get grimy looking after years of being handled and moved around.

We R Memory Keepers D-ring Album

Note how the corners are protected

How to Choose a Scrapbook Album?

Is the Album Archival Safe?

Archival safe, photo safe, and acid-free are all terms you may encounter on your scrapbooking journey. What they all mean is that the products are safe and won’t cause deterioration of your photos. Top on my list for any products I use while scrapbooking.

I’m sure you can think of a photo album you’ve seen in the past where it’s caused the picture to fade or left a sticky residue and, of course, those tape marks. Some are even impossible to remove from the old albums. Choosing archival-safe means that your pictures will last for a long, long time.

What Size Scrapbook Is Best?

This changes from person to person and project to project. I may not want to do a 12 x12 for a weekend trip or a 8 1/2 x 11 for my sons senior year of high school. But again that is each persons on decision.

Most standard scrapbooks are 12x 12 and 8 1/2 x 11. It’s common to choose one of these sizes for the majority of your scrapbooking albums. These are perfect for everyday life, family and children, or whatever you’d like. When choosing a size, think about the content that will go inside.

Other standard sizes work best when you want to scrapbook an event with a clear start and end. I recommend continuing with a standard size album that is a smaller size. The 8 x 8 or 6 x 6 also great to give as gifts. I also like these for baby gifts. After all they are a never ending album. A brag book for grandma every few months is perfect in a smaller size.

If you decide to use 8 1/2 x 11 or 8 x 8, you will often need to cut down a 12 x 12 sheet of paper to fit your album. Most card stock comes in 8 1/2 x 11, but not all. Using this can reduce some of the waste, which is a great tip for reducing cost. You are going to need to be super creative and repurpose your scraps.

How to Choose a Scrapbook Album?

Post Bound Album

A post bound album is secured by two or three posts which screw into one another to hold the pages together. One nice feature of these albums is you feel like the book is getting full, you can always add in post extenders to make it bigger.

This is probably one of the most common types of scrapbook album around. They have been around for a long time and are very popular. Choosing a post bound album has some good advantages but some disadvantages as well.

open view of post bound scrapbook album
view of closed post bound scrapbook pages

When choosing a post-bound album, be sure to inspect how many and where the post screws are in the book. If there are only two, make sure they position away from the spine’s centre. This causes the pages to drop out of the bottom of the album, not a look you will want after working so hard on your great pages.

The best post bound albums to have are three posts that are evenly spaced and are fairly close to the end of the spine. Three is better than two, but you still need to be sure they are spaced equally.

One of the nicest things about these albums is that they lay flat and display a two-page layout nicely.

Personally, I’m not a big fan of post bound albums. Adding post to a previous post is a nightmare. And often does not look as good with the longer post. I feel like after you’ve unscrewed and then re-screwed them back together a few times they get a bit worn out. (Of Note: unscrewing and re-screwing is the only way to add pages. And some times they only come with 8 to 10 pages. The album in the above picture is about fifteen-years-old, so it has held up ok, but looks nowhere near as good as my leather D-ring albums.

D-Ring Album

Similar in design to a binder. These albums have three rings that hold hole-punched page protectors. This is the most user friendly of all albums. Easily remove or add pages with the binder rings.

The downside to these albums is their weight. While they can hold a lot of pages, they can get heavy and clunky. Another thing to consider is that the pages do not lie next to one another, which may spoil the look of a two-page layout.

Even with a couple of downsides this is the album I prefer. I am currently using the We R Memory Keepers Leather 12×12 D-ring album. It’s very easy to use, is durable and I have albums that are over ten years old that look brand new.

Open view of 3 ring scrapbook album

Strap Bound Album

Bound by a plastic strap, these albums are versatile, durable and the pages lay very nicely. This is the first style of scrapbook album that I had when I first got into scrapbooking, and I know many people who still prefer to use this kind. It’s not easy to find them in stores and most buy them from an advisor at

Best Scrapbook Album Brands

After years of trial and error, I’ve created a list of brands that I think are create great, high-quality, and stylish products.

  1. We R Memory Keepers
  2. Heidi Swapp
  3. Simple Stories
  4. American Crafts

These are my suggestions, and may not work for everyone. There are a lot of brands and different albums out there, so please feel free to try out another brand that may fit your needs better.


I don’t even want to think about how much money I’ve spent on albums over the years that ended up given away or in the bin. It can be so frustrating to try to find the right album. By making sure you check the durability, longevity of the brand, type of album, cost & archival quality you will be on your way to creating a scrapbook that will last for generations.

Be sure to sign up for my newsletter to learn about new products, special and tip & tricks.

Sign up Now

How to Choose a Scrapbook Album?